Rev. Experience Mayhew was born on 27 January 1671/72 at Chilmark, Dukes County, Massachusetts. He was the son of
John Mayhew and
Elizabeth Hilliard. Rev. Experience Mayhew married
Thankful Hinckley on 12 November 1695 at Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts. Rev. Experience Mayhew married
Remember Bourne on 4 December 1711 at Sandwich, Barnstable County, Massachusetts. Rev. Experience Mayhew was Clergyman. He died on 29 November 1758 at Martha's Vineyard, Dukes County, Massachusetts, at age 86. He was buried at West Tisbury Village Cemetery, West Tisbury, Dukes County, Massachusetts.